A Comparison between movie Omkara by Vishal Bhardwaj and a play Othello by William Shakespeare
Setting & Background
Key Point: Bhardwaj keeps the core story but adapts it to the Indian political-criminal setup, making it relatable.
Characters – Othello and Omkara
Othello Character | Omkara Character | Role/Relation | Traits |
---|---|---|---|
Othello | Omkara (Omi) | Main hero, general/gang leader | Brave, respected, insecure and jealous |
Desdemona | Dolly Mishra | Othello/Omkara’s lover | Loyal, innocent, strong-hearted |
Iago | Langda Tyagi | Villain, manipulator, aide | Jealous, cunning, fake loyalty |
Cassio | Kesu Firangi | Officer, second-in-command | Charming, loyal, well-mannered |
Emilia | Indu | Wife of Langda, Dolly’s supporter | Honest, brave, speaks up too late |
Roderigo | Rajju | Foolish admirer of Desdemona/Dolly | Obsessed, tricked easily |
Brabantio | Raghunath Mishra | Father of Desdemona/Dolly | Proud, disapproves of Othello/Omi |
Duke of Venice | Tiwari Bhaisahab | Senior figure, mediator | Fair, wise, politically aware |
Montano | — | Former governor | Honest, law-abiding |
Lodovico | — | Observer of the tragedy | Calm, moral, shocked by events |
Gratiano | — | Brabantio’s brother | Supportive, arrives late |
Clown | — | Comic servant | Witty, ironic |
Sailor | — | Messenger | Minor role |
Bianca | Billo Chamanbahar | Prostitute girl Cassio’s admirer | Emotional, jealous, ignored |
Comparison of movie and play themes
- Jealousy: Langda and Iago destroy everything due to envy.
- Betrayal: The hero trusts the villain and doubts the innocent.
- Innocence Destroyed: Desdemona and Dolly are killed without fault.
- Outsider Identity: Race and caste create insecurity and isolation.
Symbols in Both Stories
Symbol | In Othello | In Omkara | Meaning |
---|---|---|---|
Token of Love | Handkerchief | Silver Waist Chain | Love turned to doubt |
The Bed | Death of Desdemona | Death of Dolly | Love ends in tragedy |
Race/Caste | Othello’s race | Omkara’s caste | Symbol of being an outsider |
Silence | Emilia speaks too late | Indu tells truth too late | Truth delayed leads to death |
Style and Language
Conclusion: One is classical, the other raw and modern—but both are powerful emotionally.
The Tragic Ending
Conclusion
Both Omkara and Othello tell the same heartbreaking story in different ways. Whether it’s a general in Venice or a gang leader in Uttar Pradesh, the emotions of love, jealousy, and betrayal are the same. Vishal Bhardwaj successfully brought Shakespeare’s classic into an Indian setting, helping us see how timeless these themes really are. By comparing the characters and symbols, we learn that human nature hasn’t changed much over the years. For students, Omkara is a great way to understand Othello in a language, culture, and style that feels closer to home.
From Venice to Uttar Pradesh, the tragedy remains timeless.